When a tiny newspaper in rural Oklahoma took on the local sheriff’s department, it probably didn’t expect to become the subject of an award-winning documentary. But that’s exactly what happened with “Kill. Bury. Print.”, a film produced by Rachel Maddow and directed by Ben Klein. The 2026 Montclair Film Festival has announced that Maddow and Klein will receive the David Carr Award for Truth in Non-Fiction Filmmaking for their work. The award, named after the legendary New York Times media columnist, honors documentaries that demonstrate exceptional commitment to uncovering truth and holding power accountable.
The film chronicles the harrowing standoff between the McCurtain County Gazette, a family-run newspaper, and the local sheriff’s office. It’s a story that feels ripped from a thriller novel: intimidation, suspicious deaths, and a community caught in the crossfire. But it’s all too real, and it underscores the vital role of local journalism in exposing corruption.
The Story Behind “Kill. Bury. Print.”
McCurtain County, Oklahoma, is the kind of place where everyone knows everyone. The Gazette, run by the Chandler family for generations, had long been a quiet chronicle of local life. But when the paper began investigating a series of deaths and disappearances connected to the sheriff’s department, the quiet ended. Threats, harassment, and even violence followed. The documentary captures the Chandlers’ relentless pursuit of the truth, often at great personal risk.
Maddow, known for her sharp political commentary and investigative journalism, brings her signature depth to the project as a producer. Klein, an acclaimed documentary filmmaker, directs with a keen eye for the human drama behind the headlines. Together, they paint a portrait of courage and resilience in the face of seemingly insurmountable power.
The title itself, “Kill. Bury. Print.”, is a chilling reference to a phrase allegedly used by those trying to suppress the story. It’s a stark reminder that journalism isn’t always safe, and that the freedom of the press is something worth fighting for.
Why the David Carr Award Matters
The David Carr Award for Truth in Non-Fiction Filmmaking was established in 2016 to honor Carr’s legacy of tough, insightful reporting. Carr, who died in 2015, was known for his searing media criticism and his unwavering support for journalists who dug deep. The award is given annually at the Montclair Film Festival to a documentary that embodies Carr’s spirit.
Previous recipients have tackled subjects like the opioid crisis, racial injustice, and political corruption. “Kill. Bury. Print.” fits squarely within that tradition. It’s not just a true-crime story; it’s a story about the necessity of a free press and the dangers of unchecked authority.
Thom Powers, the festival’s documentary curator, praised the film for its bravery and its timely message. “In an era where local news is vanishing, this film reminds us why it matters,” he said in a statement. The award will be presented at a ceremony during the festival, which runs from April 24 to May 3, 2026, in Montclair, New Jersey.
The Fight for Local Journalism
“Kill. Bury. Print.” arrives at a moment when local newspapers across the United States are struggling to survive. According to a 2024 report from Northwestern University’s Medill School of Journalism, more than 2,500 local newspapers have closed since 2005, leaving many communities without a reliable source of local news. This phenomenon, often called “news deserts,” has far-reaching consequences: less accountability, lower voter turnout, and increased polarization.
The McCurtain County Gazette is one of the lucky ones. It’s still publishing, thanks in part to the attention brought by the documentary. But the Chandlers’ story is a cautionary tale. Without local watchdogs, who will hold sheriffs, mayors, and school boards accountable? The film makes a compelling case that we all suffer when local journalism dies.
Maddow, in a statement about the award, said, “This film is a tribute to the stubborn, unglamorous work of local reporters who refuse to look away. Ben and I are honored to receive this award in David Carr’s name, and we hope it shines a light on the critical importance of supporting local news.”
What’s Next for the Filmmakers?
Maddow and Klein are no strangers to ambitious projects. Maddow’s previous documentary work includes “Bag Man,” about the Spiro Agnew scandal, and “Ultra,” about a fascist plot to overthrow the U.S. government. Klein directed “The Sentence” and “The Wolfpack,” both of which premiered at Sundance. Their collaboration on “Kill. Bury. Print.” has already generated buzz on the festival circuit, with screenings at Toronto and DOC NYC.
Following the Montclair award, the film is expected to be picked up by a major streaming platform, though no deal has been announced yet. It will also be screened at select theaters in Oklahoma and Texas, giving local audiences a chance to see their story on the big screen. For the Chandlers, it’s a moment of validation. “We never set out to be heroes,” said publisher Chris Chandler. “We just wanted to tell the truth. This award is for every small-town journalist who keeps going.”
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the David Carr Award?
The David Carr Award for Truth in Non-Fiction Filmmaking is presented annually by the Montclair Film Festival to a documentary that exemplifies the late journalist’s commitment to truth and accountability. It was first awarded in 2016.
Who are Rachel Maddow and Ben Klein?
Rachel Maddow is an Emmy-winning television host, author, and producer known for her work on MSNBC. Ben Klein is a documentary director whose films include “The Wolfpack” and “The Sentence.”
What is “Kill. Bury. Print.” about?
The documentary follows the McCurtain County Gazette, a small family-run newspaper in Oklahoma, as it investigates corruption and misconduct within the local sheriff’s department, facing threats and intimidation.
When and where will the award be presented?
The 2026 Montclair Film Festival runs from April 24 to May 3, 2026, in Montclair, New Jersey. The award ceremony will take place during the festival.
How can I watch “Kill. Bury. Print.”?
The film is currently screening at festivals. A streaming release is expected later in 2026. Check the Montclair Film Festival website for screening times.